After the 921 earthquake, principle of the NJNU, Lee Chia Tung, led all the teachers and students evacuated from PuLi and re-schooled at the NTU in Taipei. This re-school case has caused opposite/polarize disputes/opinions, support or critique. This research is based on 45 readers’ opinions from the 3 main journals, “ the China Times”, “ the United Papers” and “ the Free Times”.Choosing the Cluster Critiques in Rhetoric Critiques as the author’s point of view to analysis, present and compare the two opposite disputes. Furthermore, researching deeply the opposite side of the NJNU re-chool about their value of worth and world under the rhetoric operation, and the rhetoric motivation by the 5 key phrases– “community consciousness”, “education” ,“the NJNU man”, “Lee Chia Tung” and “ right”.