1998年年會論文 -領導型態、性別、與領導效能:從性別角色相符論談起
篇名
領導型態、性別、與領導效能:從性別角色相符論談起
Leadership Styles, Gender, and Leadership Effectiveness: A study on Sex Roles Congruence Theory
作者
李秀珠、林乾文
Li, Shu-Chu Sarrina、Lin, Chen Wen
中文摘要
根據性別角色相符理論之觀點,男女性應擁有非常不同的特點與個性,而男性所擁有之特徵常被視為較重要,而且是成功\領導者不可或缺之要素,而女性之特徵則被視為與成功\的領導者之特徵是不能相容的,所以當女性試著去表現出傳統上屬於男性之領導行為時,因為為違反了性別角色之期望,反而導致部屬之反感。本研究主要目的乃是檢視領導型態,性別,與領導效能三者之相關性為何,並以性別角色相符理論 (Sex - role congruence theory) 來架構本研究之理論基礎。

本研究以卷調查之方式來收集資料。問卷內容除了三個主要變項,領導型態,領導者性別,及領導效能之外,尚包括一些人口變項之資料。本研究以媒體公司為發放對象,共發出300份問卷,回收了250份有效問卷,回答問卷者必須起碼有一個上司才可填答本問卷。

本研究之研究結果支持了性別角色相符理論,當男女性採用有效率的領導型態時,部屬給予顯著不同之評價,因為傳統上男性是天生之領導者,所以有效率之領導型態應是男性所使用的,當女性用此一領導類型時,其得分反而不如同樣採用此領導類型之男性。
英文摘要
According to the sex roles congruence theory, men and women are supposed to have very different traits, and the male traits are considered to be critical for effective leadership, while the female traits are perceived as incompatible with a good leader. These sex roles stereotypes influence perceptions of leadership styles, so that when females adopt masculine leadership styles, they receive negative reactions because they violate the expectations of sex roles congruence. Based on the sex roles congruence theory, this study examined the interrelationships among leadership styles, gender, and leadership effectiveness.

A questionnaire survey was adopted for data collection of this study. The findings of the study support the sex roles congruence theory, showing that the same leadership style received a very different evaluation when it was from another gender. More results were discussed in the paper.
中文關鍵詞
領導形態,性別,領導效能,性別角色,相符理論
英文關鍵詞
leadership style,gender,efficiency,sex role,congruence theoty
發表日期
授權狀況
已授權